Our detectives are back with the following intel on this WordPress site
The site is using the Spike theme by MyThemeShop .
We could identify 5 plugins (there might be more) - iThemes Security (formerly Better WP Security) , Ultimate Posts Widget , Yoast SEO , WordPress Review Plugin: The Ultimate Solution for Building a Review Website and WP Shortcode by MyThemeShop
Create reviews! Choose from Stars, Percentages or Points for review scores. Supports Retina Display, WPMU & Unlimited Color Schemes.